top of page

Our Menu

Eddy's on Third Hayward WI Logo Dark

World Famous Grub

For Starters

Classic Wisconsin Cheese Curds image

Classic Wisconsin Cheese Curds

The ultimate curd, freshly prepared, and served hot for the ultimate indulgence. Enjoy with our house made ranch or try one of our signature fry sauces.


"Shrimply" the Best image

"Shrimply" the Best

Shrimpin' ain't easy! Try our shrimp, hand rolled with secret ingredients, deep fried to perfection, and paired with our homemade ginger and garlic sauce.


Dill-icious Pickle Chips image

Dill-icious Pickle Chips

Not your ordinary pickle chip! Crispy on the outside, party on the inside with a unique flavor profile you aren't going to find anywhere else. We pair these with our house made ranch, served hot to enjoy.


Lotzza Mozza Sticks image

Lotzza Mozza Sticks

"The Godfather" approved mozzarella sticks, hand wrapped to Ed's unique specification, and served with house made Italian Marinara sauce.


You Say 'Potato', I Say "YES PLEASE!" image

You Say 'Potato', I Say "YES PLEASE!"

This ain't your run of the mill french fry! These babies are hand cut everyday using the coldest of water to ensure high quality, deep fried to order, and seasoned with our secret spice combination. Pair it with Ed's or Erica's house made fry sauce.


Make You Scream "Poutine" image

Make You Scream "Poutine"

A dish born in Canada, but aged to perfection in the states. Ed traveled the world to find many of his recipes and this is one of them. Hand cut french fries smothered in melted mozzarella cheese and topped with homemade fresh mushroom gravy. Everybody say, "Auf jedenfall!"


Eddy's Famous Reuben Rolls image

Eddy's Famous Reuben Rolls

This appetizer is one of a kind, much like the owner. These rolls are like a reuben remixed, deep fried, and served with our house made 1000 Island Dressing.


"Put a ring on it" Onion Rings image

"Put a ring on it" Onion Rings

We went through a lot of trial and error, but ended up with the perfect breading and seasoning for our onion rings. These are truly something to write home about and they are served up hot and crispy with our house made ranch dressing.


Smash Burgers

All of our burgers are made from the highest quality Black Angus and seasoned in house.

"It's A Classic" Smashburger  image

"It's A Classic" Smashburger

We like our burgers like we like our cars, classic and made with the best and by the best. Enjoy a juicy 1/2 pound of Black Angus beef burger, smashed, and topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and mayonnaise. Want cheese? No problem! Ask your friendly cashier for your options.


Popper Bomb Burger image

Popper Bomb Burger

Indulge in the explosive flavors of this burger! Sink your teeth into a juicy 1/2 pound of perfectly cooked Black Angus beef, topped with a crispy deep-fried cream cheese patty, coated in our signature breading that has just the right amount of heat with fresh jalapeños. This burger packs a flavor punch!


Olive Explosion Burger image

Olive Explosion Burger

A fan favorite for sure! A 1/2 pound Black Angus smash burger topped with a deep fried cream cheese patty, a healthy portion of Italian green olives, and smothered in our house made garlic aioli.


Mushroom and Swiss Burger

Our 1/2 lb Black Angus smash burger smothered in sautéed portobello mushrooms, melted swiss, and drizzled in our aioli.



Our sandwiches are one of a kind and made from the highest quality meats and ingredients.

Bourbon Chicken BLT image

Bourbon Chicken BLT

A grilled chicken breast topped with pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, crispy applewood back, and two of our hand breaded onion rings. As if that wasn't enough, we top it with our bourbon sauce and place it on a toasted brioche bun.


Classic Reuben image

Classic Reuben

House roasted corned beef, sliced thin, and piled high with sauerkraut. We then drizzle this classic with house made 1000 island dressing and put it on marble rye bread.


Cashew Chicken image

Cashew Chicken

A grilled chicken breast smothered in sautéed cashews, swiss cheese, and drizzled with our homemade Garlic Aioli.


The Italian Beef image

The Italian Beef

One of our most asked for sandwiches and it's no mystery as to why. We put Eddy's homemade Italian beef and melted provolone on a toasted hoagie bun and serve it with homemade au jus and giardiniera.


The Italian Beef "Combo" image

The Italian Beef "Combo"

Eddy's famous Italian Beef with a grilled Italian Sausage sourced straight from Chicago and served with house made giardiniera, and au ju. Ask for our homemade marinara.


3 Cheese Grilled Cheese image

3 Cheese Grilled Cheese

A new take on an American classic! Cheddar, pepper jack, and american cheese topped with thick sliced of applewood bacon, tomato, and drizzled with our house made Garlic Aioli.


The Boss image

The Boss

This sandwich is large and in charge! Hand sliced beef tenderloin grilled to perfection with portobello mushrooms, tossed in our bourbon sauce, and served on a grilled hoagie bun.


Grilled Portobello Mushroom (Vegan Option) image

Grilled Portobello Mushroom (Vegan Option)


Nashville Hot Chicken image

Nashville Hot Chicken

Hand breaded marinated chicken breast sourced straight from the heart of Nashville TN (just kidding), topped with pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and homemade pickle slices drizzled with Eddy's chipotle sauce on a toasted bun.


Pork Schnitzel

We like big loins and we cannot lie! A huge smashed pork loin, breaded, deep fried, and smothered with our house made mushroom gravy then placed on a toasted bun.


"Off the Cone" Gyros (Tuesday & Saturday Only) image

"Off the Cone" Gyros (Tuesday & Saturday Only)


Weekly Sandwich Special - Ahi Tuna Melt image

Weekly Sandwich Special - Ahi Tuna Melt

Ahi Tuna Steak, fire seared, shredded and mixed with our super secret ingredient combination. It is then placed on white bread with homemade pickles, onion and cheddar cheese, and toasted on the grill to melted perfection.



Black and Bleu Salad image

Black and Bleu Salad

Delicious beef tenderloin cooked fresh and perfectly seasoned with hints of rosemary. Spring mix salad is accompanied by onions, tomato, house made croutons, and homemade blue cheese dressing.


Southwest Chicken Salad image

Southwest Chicken Salad

Diced chicken breast, tomato, crispy applewood bacon, fresh roasted corn, pepper, and onions served on a bed of spring greens and topped with our amazing homemade Southwest Ranch Dressing.


Chicken Cashew Salad image

Chicken Cashew Salad

Grilled chicken breast, cashews, swiss cheese, tomatoes, and onion served on a bed of spring greens and topped with our homemade Garlic Aioli Dressing.


Kid's Menu

Smaller portions for smaller stomachs but we keep the quality adult sized. All kid's meals come with a free drink (slushy included), side of fries, and a chocolate chip cookie.

"Pint Sized" Smash Burger image

"Pint Sized" Smash Burger

Small black Angus beef burger, smashed, and made to order.


"Pint Sized" Smash Cheeseburger image

"Pint Sized" Smash Cheeseburger

Small black Angus beef burger, smashed, and made to order with a slice of American cheese.


"Cluck, Cluck" Chicken Tenders image

"Cluck, Cluck" Chicken Tenders

Three chicken tenders, deep fried, and served with a side of sauce upon request.


Classic Grilled Cheese image

Classic Grilled Cheese

Perfectly melted and delicious! American cheese and fresh white bread, made to order on the grill.


Sandwich Side Upgrades

Who doesn't like an upgrade? If you're not feeling fries, choose another side!

Onion Rings image

Onion Rings


Fresh Side Salad



Fountain Soda / Slushy image

Fountain Soda / Slushy


Bottled Soda


Bottle Water


Adult Beverages image

Adult Beverages

Not for online sale or pick up. In store only.


Sweet Treats "Desserts"

All desserts are made from scratch, in house. You know it's good if Aunt Cindy makes it!

Homemade Brownies image

Homemade Brownies


Homemade Cookies image

Homemade Cookies


"Cool Kids" Gear

Eddy's on Third T Shirts image

Eddy's on Third T Shirts



Eddy's on Third Trucker Hats image

Eddy's on Third Trucker Hats


bottom of page